Surviving sexual assault is one of the most traumatic experiences a person will experience in their lifetime. Fortunately, our society has resources to help survivors overcome the pain, stigma and emotional turmoil of sexual assault, and the law is one of the most powerful tools on your side.
Survivors of sexual assault can pursue justice against their perpetrators through two legal avenues: criminal and civil court.
The Basics
Criminal Law
A criminal case is when the government goes after the accused. The burden of proof, or what is required for the accused to be found guilty, is “beyond a reasonable doubt.” In other words, based on the facts presented, there is no other logical explanation for who committed the crime.
A defendant found guilty faces punishment, which generally involves penalties and/or jail time. Since the state litigates these cases, the assault survivor has little to no say in what happens during the trial or what type of punishment is sought against the perpetrator.
Advantages of Criminal Court For Assault Victims
Criminal cases can provide a sense of relief to survivors by having the community and the eyes of the law recognize the perpetrator as the person guilty of committing the heinous act. Seeing that person punished for their crime can lighten a survivor’s burden. This may be especially true if the perpetrator serves jail time and is removed from society for awhile, unable to harm other innocent members of the public.
Civil Law
On the other hand, a civil case is when one party sues another party for some kind of injury committed against them. The burden of proof for these cases is lower than in criminal proceedings. The judge or jury will decide if the accused is liable based on a “preponderance of evidence.” This means it is more likely than not that the accused committed the injurious act.
If found liable, the defendant (perpetrator) will pay money to the plaintiff (assault survivor). Because a civil proceeding is entirely initiated by the plaintiff, he or she will be heavily involved in the proceedings and help determine the amount of compensation sought from the defendant.
The Advantages of Civil Court
Like a guilty verdict in a criminal proceeding, a favorable verdict in a civil case can be a source of comfort for the survivor. The perpetrator’s guilt for the crime is effectively acknowledged by society. Furthermore, the monies won in a civil proceeding can provide the financial means to help a survivor recover.
Survivors often face a range of economic hardships, depending on their circumstances – such as a college student missing school and needing therapy, to a spouse losing everything after leaving an abusive marriage. In many cases, a civil proceeding is crucial to helping an assault survivor move on positively with their life.
Read more:
New Bill to End Secrecy Behind Doctor Sexual Assault
Riverside Third-Grader Accused of Sexual Assault
Sexual Assault at the Hands of Your Doctor?
Related Posts
Can you file a sexual assault lawsuit without making your identity public? California courts may allow survivors to proceed as Jane Doe. An attorney can help you understand the court approval process, what privacy protections may be available, and what happens if those protections are violated.
The public response to sexual assault allegations at Cornell University has raised difficult questions about survivor privacy. Jessica Pride reflects on why survivors deserve control over their identities and when and how their stories are told.
After a sexual assault at work, how do you decide what to do next. Knowing what to consider now and the legal options available can help you make informed decisions about your safety and your job.
A sexual assault at an Airbnb can raise questions about responsibility beyond the person who committed the assault. Hosts, property owners, Airbnb, and other parties could also face a civil claim.
When child sexual abuse happens at school, the school may also bear responsibility. Understanding negligence, mandated reporting, and school liability can help survivors and families explore their legal options.
Workplace sexual misconduct can raise difficult questions about an employer’s responsibility, reporting to HR, and protecting your rights. California survivors may have legal options based on who was involved and how the employer responded.
After a sexual assault at an Airbnb, you may be facing difficult decisions far from home. Jessica Pride explains what to consider now and how to protect your options when you’re ready.
Hotel employees may encounter signs of exploitation that others never see. Recognizing patterns of control and unusual activity can help identify potential sex trafficking and raise questions about a hotel's responsibility to respond.
